André Onana’s move from Inter to Manchester United in 2023 is the cleanest example of a recruitment habit that has gone too far. He was bought, by any reasonable reading, because he could play out from the back for Erik ten Hag. He had been very good at that at Ajax and Inter. What a goalkeeper is actually there to do, which is stop the ball going in, was treated as the thing you could assume.
You can’t assume it.
The Ederson effect
The template comes from Manchester City. When Pep Guardiola signed Ederson from Benfica in 2017, the pitch was that a goalkeeper could be an extra outfield player in possession, and City’s build-up has leaned on that ever since. It worked because Guardiola’s whole system was built to use it. Ederson’s passing was one component in a machine with a specific purpose.
Most clubs copying it don’t have the machine. They have a goalkeeper who is comfortable on the ball and a back line that doesn’t know what to do when he gets it to them. The distribution becomes a talking point in the summer and a liability by October, when a pressed pass goes astray and everyone remembers what the position is for.

What gets lost
Shot-stopping, command of the box and decisions on crosses are less glamorous, harder to show in a highlight reel, and in my view far more valuable per point of the goalkeeper’s job. A keeper who adds a little in possession but concedes goals he should save is a net negative, however neat his left foot looks on a Sunday afternoon.
The cruelty is that the skills are not mutually exclusive. Alisson at Liverpool is the proof: elite with his hands and feet. But he is a rare player, and the mistake is treating his profile as the baseline instead of the exception.
A smaller point
It’s also telling how rarely clubs describe a goalkeeper signing as “a better shot-stopper.” It’s almost always “comfortable in possession.” The vocabulary of the transfer market has drifted away from the job.
The sensible correction is boring: rank the saves first, the claims second, and the passing a distant third. Then build your press-resistant buildup around whoever you have, rather than the other way round. Clubs that do this will look unfashionable and take more points than the ones recruiting a playmaker in gloves.